Planet X Town Hall

From www.spaceobs.org ......

Is there a relationship between the conjunctions of comet Elenin and earthquakes on Earth?
 April 21st, 2011 |  Author: Leonid Elenin
This questions one of more popular and I decide to make dedicate topic about this subject. Below you can see all significant earthquakes on Earth (from 7-th magnitude by Richter scale and higher), as well as relative position of Solar System planets and the comet C/2010 X1 (Elenin). All data about earthquakes taken from the USGS site.

Magnitude 7.1 NEAR THE EAST COAST OF HONSHU, JAPAN April 07, 2011



Magnitude 9.0 NEAR THE EAST COAST OF HONSHU, JAPAN March 11, 2011



Magnitude 7.2 NEAR THE EAST COAST OF HONSHU, JAPAN March 09, 2011



Magnitude 7.2 SOUTHWESTERN PAKISTAN January 18, 2011



Magnitude 7.0 LOYALTY ISLANDS January 13, 2011



Magnitude 7.1 ARAUCANIA, CHILE January 02, 2011



Magnitude 7.0 SANTIAGO DEL ESTERO, ARGENTINA January 01, 2011



Magnitude 7.3 VANUATU REGION December 25, 2010



Magnitude 7.4 BONIN ISLANDS, JAPAN REGION December 21, 2010



Magnitude 7.7 KEPULAUAN MENTAWAI REGION, INDONESIA October 25, 2010



Magnitude 7.2 NEAR THE SOUTH COAST OF PAPUA, INDONESIA September 29, 2010



Magnitude 7.0 SOUTH ISLAND OF NEW ZEALAND September 03, 2010



Magnitude 7.1 ECUADOR August 12, 2010



Magnitude 7.3 VANUATU August 10, 2010



Magnitude 7.0 NEW BRITAIN REGION, PAPUA NEW GUINEA August 04, 2010



Magnitude 7.6 MORO GULF, MINDANAO, PHILIPPINES July 23, 2010



Magnitude 7.0 NEAR THE NORTH COAST OF PAPUA, INDONESIA June 16, 2010



Magnitude 7.8 NORTHERN SUMATRA, INDONESIA April 06, 2010



Magnitude 7.2 BAJA CALIFORNIA, MEXICO April 04, 2010



Magnitude 8.8 OFFSHORE BIO-BIO, CHILE February 27, 2010



Magnitude 7.0 HAITI REGION January 12, 2010



Magnitude 7.1 SOLOMON ISLANDS January 03, 2010



No comments,  your can make own conclusions… I just want to note that on March 11 2011, to the conjunction the comet with the Earth remained 3 days. Is it large or little time interval? I think it’s difficult to judge.

 Posted in News |  Tags: C/2010 X1 (Elenin), Comet, Comet Elenin, Комета, Комета Еленина 29 Responses to “Is there a relationship between the conjunctions of comet Elenin and earthquakes on Earth?”
 kingkevin says:
%A %B %e%q, %Y at %I:%M %p
So…your backing up the fact that each times its earth elenin sun it’s a big quake? I mean i’m so uncertain about this. Once is coincidence I could see that. 2 is odd, but still passable. But 3 large destructive quakes the last 3 times it has lined up with us and the sun seems far fetched to call a coincidence. I hear what your saying, and what the gov is saying, and the media….oh wait, they’re not reporting on any of this. But I understand what your saying that it’s not, but the facts and research shows….it is! So what can one possibly think of the situation? It’s extremely difficult to come out with a straight answer anywhere supporting either side. But JPL clearly shows, Feb 27 2010, Sep 5 2010, and March 11 2010 as alignments. These three alignments also sparked unknown anomalies like being moved off the axis? Whirlpools? Weird magnetic field? People NEED and want answers. Not what ifs…they can have those on their own. Thank you.

 GLPac says:
%A %B %e%q, %Y at %I:%M %p
So what you are saying is that this year is going to be a bad one when it lines up in September/October.

What do you think of the theory that there is actually a Brown Dwarf following Elenin (or the other way around i should say) about one month behind?

Pictures from this lady “Amy” who posted them in the comments below the article on this website: http://sydneystargazers.com/2011/04/16/16th-april-2011-notes-orbit-of-elenin-16th-april/ show Elenin, and then a red body of mass that looks eerily similar to the “hoax” red planet picture that surfaced on the internet awhile back.

Thanks

 Stewart says:
%A %B %e%q, %Y at %I:%M %p
There really does seem a likely link to some of these, and the more I read about the electric universe, electrically charged comets etc the more evidence there seems to be.

 Andrew says:
%A %B %e%q, %Y at %I:%M %p
Can someone explain, or post a link to some info that explains the difference between the 2 diagrams in each image above? It appears to illustrate 2 different paths recorded on the same date?

 Leonid Elenin says:
%A %B %e%q, %Y at %I:%M %p
Can someone explain, or post a link to some info that explains the difference between the 2 diagrams in each image above? It appears to illustrate 2 different paths recorded on the same date?

I can explain. Left side of picture show conjunction with terrestrial planets (Mercury, Venus, Earth and Mars), the right side demonstrate conjunctions with distant giant planets.

 Grant says:
%A %B %e%q, %Y at %I:%M %p
I very much would like a response to GLP, kingkevin, and Stewart’s questions…

 edgar says:
%A %B %e%q, %Y at %I:%M %p
Comets do not produce earthquakes and conjunctions are not perfect.

1. a comet is far away and is small in comparison to the earth has a gravitational influence ridiculously small.

2. There can be no perfect alignment, as both the comet, the earth, have different inclination angles.

Leonid I did not need this article, the mind of the conspiracy always tends to relate everything that has no real relationship.

Edgar

 Kenneth says:
%A %B %e%q, %Y at %I:%M %p
Keep watching the sky for Planet X (Nibiru). There is evidence Google removed the coordinates from their software google sky so that people cannot see it. Microsoft too. But people like you can see it so keep looking for it and keep us informed at your website.

 Alphada SATRIANSA says:
%A %B %e%q, %Y at %I:%M %p
Thank you Mr. Leonard ELENIN for this preliminary investigation regarding whether there were conjunctions between comet Elenin alignment with Earth, and earthquakes on Earth..

Me myself already did a similar comparisons on my facebook note “THE STORY OF ELENIN” @ https://www.facebook.com/note.php?note_id=10150168364898505
I made comparisons between comet Elenin trajectory from NASA JPL orbital diagram, and earthquakes data from USGS.

In my opinion, yes there were several conincidences between alignments of comet Elenin and Earth with other celestial bodies such as Sun or other planets with eartquakes.. The alignment combinations can be made up of Elenin-Earth-Sun, Elenin-Earth-Jupiter, Elenin-Earth-Venus, etc.

In refer to your question,” that on March 11 2011, to the conjunction the comet with the Earth remained 3 days. Is it large or little time interval?”
This question impress me that when the comet getting closer, then the effect will also be getting more bigger, thus a few days or more before the exact alignment, the ‘superposition’ of gravity field would already effective on Earth. Subsequently on 11 April 2011 the alignment of Elenin-Earth-Venus (the distance between Elenin and Earth was 1.873AU) had a coincidence with Fukushima earhtquake at 7.1SR. (what a big influence..?)

From these coincidences, I think it is not a bad idea to bring along more sophisticated telescopes (on ground, and or on orbit) to get a better empirical data not only visually but also its characteristic on gravity, magnetic, and heat prior September 2011.

Keep on the good work..!

 Aditya says:
%A %B %e%q, %Y at %I:%M %p
What is the second image in every image? i mean the one to the right? So… if this thing is really Nibiru, should we start preparing? When will we get to see it with the naked eye , if this comet is REALLY that big i.e 3 to 4 times the size jupiter… or is this comet revolving around Nibiru that is coming behind it, that we cannot see at the moment?

 Dave says:
%A %B %e%q, %Y at %I:%M %p
I also noticed this eq relationship, posted on fb about the alignment only days before the Japan quake.

Disagree with you Edgar, you cannot know for certain what you say, reason being is that the Earth is a conductor and could be at sufficient charge differential, allowing an electrical coupling to occur. I am not talking about coulomb’s electrostatic forces or gravity, i’m talking about a flow of charge, much like the charge characteristics within a vacuum tube. Charge can flow in a vacuum!

Tell me Edgar what potential difference, and charge capacity might we expect?
I was in one of those earthquakes listed above, and saw a vivid resonating plasma in the sky above just as the main primary shock wave was generated? For me the correlation is obvious – there are charge couplings occuring.

There is no need for an exacting geometric alignment either… when the distance, potential differences, and temperatures etc are tuned to trigger a coupling.

 Leonid Elenin says:
%A %B %e%q, %Y at %I:%M %p
What is the second image in every image? i mean the one to the right?

I already answer on this question. Left side of picture show conjunction with terrestrial planets (Mercury, Venus, Earth and Mars), the right side demonstrate conjunctions with distant giant planets.

So… if this thing is really Nibiru, should we start preparing? When will we get to see it with the naked eye , if this comet is REALLY that big i.e 3 to 4 times the size jupiter… or is this comet revolving around Nibiru that is coming behind it, that we cannot see at the moment?

We can’t see this comet by naked eye because this object is relative small comet, not a planet. If comet Elenin is Nibiru, we already catch it without any binoculars and telescopes. Comet coma is semi transparency and such large object as planet can’t lurking behind my comet. This is rubbish.

 Leonid Elenin says:
%A %B %e%q, %Y at %I:%M %p
Keep watching the sky for Planet X (Nibiru). There is evidence Google removed the coordinates from their software google sky so that people cannot see it. Microsoft too.

I already answered on this question. And I will post it on FAQ page.

Please read this http://spaceobs.org/2011/04/10/comet-elenin-continues-to-increase-in-size-and-another-close-approach-with-a-large-main-belt-asteroid/comment-page-2/#comment-3623

 Stewart says:
%A %B %e%q, %Y at %I:%M %p
Leonid
What are your views on whether Elenin has smaller bodies accompanying it?

 Grant says:
%A %B %e%q, %Y at %I:%M %p
Any updates on the comet’s size? I remember there being an instance where an amateur astronomer posted his calculations different from NASA and resulted in the forums being shut down…

 Аркадий says:
%A %B %e%q, %Y at %I:%M %p
Леонид, выяснил наконец полностью, что комета летит не одна – на снимках фото видно ещё 3 объекта, т.е. смысл заключается в том, что это в целом “нечто”) Да, Лёня, вы открыли то, что будет кое-чем из ряда вон выходящим, и от этого я только горжусь за соотечественника! Естественно, я могу предположить, что это за объекты и просто так ничего не происходит – так чья это активность?
Дух времени само собой присутствует в нынешнее время. Но мы все свободны в нашем выборе. И каждому лучше его сделать осознанно.
Спасибо,Леонид!

 Leonid Elenin says:
%A %B %e%q, %Y at %I:%M %p
Аркадий, я могу лишь полностью опровергнуть ваше сообщение.

 Cyrus says:
%A %B %e%q, %Y at %I:%M %p
Leonid, thank you so much for confronting this pressing question on the minds of so many of your fans. A definite pattern is emerging concerning Comet Elenin and planetary alignments involving both our sun and the Earth. The two largest earthquakes over the past 15 months both occurred during alignments with Comet Elenin and a third alignment on Sept. 3, 2010 resulted in the first Christchurch 7.0 earthquake. The coincidense of these large and extremely rare earthquake events happening during an alignment with a single comet also involving the sun and earth three times are too great to be mathimatically probable in my humble opinion. An object of great mass in our solar system, it would seem to appear could only trigger such rare seismic events. Also the closer Comet Elenin has drawn to the interior of the solar system the more and more earth changes we seem to be experiencing with the incredible increase in worldwide seismic activity and also volcanism. So is it really any wonder that people of the earth are questioning if Elenin truly is a comet or a planetary body of some sort? Also during the last planetary alignment with comet Elenin on March 11, 2011 our sun was also extremely active with an X class solar Flare event occurring on March 9 and also several M class and C class solar Flares occurring at this very same time period. The earth also was experiencing a geomagnetic storm of Level-G1 and Level G-2 for three days from March 10-12 as a result of earth directed solar coronal mass ejections. So it appears that comet Elenin may have some sort of electromagnetic effect upon the sun which also directly effects the earth. Only time will reveal if the next alignment on Sept. 26, 2011 will bring us even more seismic activity.

 Amy Evans says:
%A %B %e%q, %Y at %I:%M %p
If, and I mean if this Elenin is just a small comet … how would it have enough Gravitational Mass to our Earth from all the way out there? And if it should have the ability to effect our Planet from that distance, what will it (They)be able to do when it comes closer in October of this year?

Amy

 Kevin Heider says:
%A %B %e%q, %Y at %I:%M %p
On average there is a quake greater than magnitude 7 every month. On any given day there is about a 4% chance of a mag 7+ Earthquake (15 quakes/365 days=0.041). Given an error range of ±5°, on any given day there is also a 5.5% chance of an “alignment”. (10/180=0.055. 180° is a straight line and “10 = the range 0-5 and also 175-180.” During the Japan quake the comet alignment was 175.8°) These statements make interesting statistics, but not proven science.
http://earthquake.usgs.gov/earthquakes/eqarchives/year/eqstats.php

 Leonid Elenin says:
%A %B %e%q, %Y at %I:%M %p
On average there is a quake greater than magnitude 7 every month. On any given day there is about a 4% chance of a mag 7+ Earthquake (15 quakes/365 days=0.041). Given an error range of ±5°, on any given day there is also a 5.5% chance of an «alignment». (10/180=0.055. 180° is a straight line and «10 = the range 0-5 and also 175-180.» During the Japan quake the comet alignment was 175.8°) These statements make interesting statistics, but not proven science.

If, and I mean if this Elenin is just a small comet … how would it have enough Gravitational Mass to our Earth from all the way out there? And if it should have the ability to effect our Planet from that distance, what will it (They)be able to do when it comes closer in October of this year?

Kevin, thanks for very interesting statistics. I absolutely agree with you, science can’t explain influence comet on Earth. I’m sure that this is not the gravitational influence.
Electric Universe? Perhaps there is no relation at all.

 Amy Evans says:
%A %B %e%q, %Y at %I:%M %p
Thank you Leonid 

 Leonid Elenin says:
%A %B %e%q, %Y at %I:%M %p
You’re welcome, Amy.

 Daggerstab says:
%A %B %e%q, %Y at %I:%M %p
Leonid,

You can do a few control comparisons with other comets, for example with 29P/Schwassmann-Wachmann. 

Does answering the wacky comments here leave you any time for stargazing? 

Поздрави от България!
Daggerstab

 Ems D says:
%A %B %e%q, %Y at %I:%M %p
Hi Leonid

I’m wondering what links are with Nasa on your comet’s find. Do you agree on data?

Also Asteroid 2005 YU55 arriving shortly after the comet is 400m in diameter approaching at 0.85 lunar distances. That makes it a quarter a size of the moon approximately and 15 per cent closer than the moon. Knowing the lunar tidal effects please can you identify if you consider that gravitational effects particularly to tides may be caused by this object.

Re 2005 YU55
http://neo.jpl.nasa.gov/news/news171.html

 Drew says:
%A %B %e%q, %Y at %I:%M %p
YU55 is interesting because it passes inside the earth and moon’s orbit around the time we should be passing through the tail of Elenin’s comet.

 Cyrus says:
%A %B %e%q, %Y at %I:%M %p
Kevin,

On average there is only ONE 8.0 magnitude or larger earthquake per year, so please calculate the probability of their being an alignment with one single comet and the earth and sun during two separate massive earthquakes which occur only once per year? And then figure in the probability of a third alignment occurring during a 7.0 magnitude earthquake over a 14 month period of time?

Just because so called modern science at this time cannot explain the correlation between Comet Elenin and the apparent seismic events which have manifested doesn’t negate that there is a relationship. Astrophysicist, James McCanney has written several books on comet theory and electromagnetism which appear to better explain such a relationship. Since modern science isn’t able to explain the apparent relationship that these alignments are exerting upon the earth, then it would be most prudent to look for alternative theories outside the mainstream of science by learned individuals with the education, knowledge and experience to intelligently offer up alternative theories. I believe that James McCanney from Cornell University is such an individual and that we shouldn’t dismiss his comet theories especially when his alternative theories about an electric Universe, possibly explain what we see happening with Comet Elenin in relationship to the increase in seismic activity. It is my opinion that there is not a casual relationship between these events.

 Lyndon Eaton says:
%A %B %e%q, %Y at %I:%M %p
Thanks again Mr. Elenin for taking the time to answer these questions. I agree with you, there may not be any relationship to the comet and earthquakes on earth. This could easily be coincidences. I am still curious about the size of the comet, and other objects that will approach us at the same time. It is also quite compelling to see the comet go in front of earth around oct. 22. i wonder if the tail will have debris in it that would enter our atmosphere? Thanks again for your difficult research. Lyndon

 Jason says:
%A %B %e%q, %Y at %I:%M %p
Thank you for posting. Having looked into the dates with my limited knowledge of gravitational effect, orbital resonance etc the only thing I can see with any kind of regular occurrence is Jupiter being in alignment, in several cases with Sol, Saturn, Uranus and other planets – and in other cases with Sol and comet Elenin. There seems to be a lot more involved regarding gravitational effects causing earthquakes than just the alignment with Elenin and the Earth. I’ll be looking into solar events around these dates as well. have a great day
Rgds
Jason

A friend of mine from another group has been enhancing the Russian Photo of Elenin, and I have been posting them here today ... he recently did another enhancement, and believes he has found two objects orbiting around the central body ... the image is weird though ... ELEnin appears to be smiling ... I have asked him about this, and I am awaiting his responce

Many blog readers have already seen the latest pictures of the comet C/2010 X1 . They tail of a comet's tail extends only 1 arc minute of arc. Is the comet's tail a little or is it just an optical illusion? For their calculations, I used a picture Gustavo Muller (Gustavo Muler) received by him on March 7. Unfortunately, the confrontation of the comet, we could not get her shots on the large telescopes - the camera is out of order seven foot telescope Folkesa (Faulkes Telescope North, FTN).

So, back to the existing snapshot. When approaching a confrontation, when the comet, the Earth and the Sun would be in line (ie, the angle C-C-W will be close to 180 °), the tail of a comet is almost hidden from the eyes of the terrestrial observer, because the tails of comets are directed away from the Sun. At the time of shooting, we saw the tail of the comet at an angle of only 2.75 °! Adopting the length of the projection of the tail for 1 arc minute of arc and solving triangles we see that the actual length of the tail of a comet has exceeded 900 000 km! Although in fact the tail should be even more so as Gustavo used only 30-cm telescope, it is clear that by removing at the same time a comet on a 2-m telescope, we would see the weaker parts of the tail of a comet.

If the March 7 we could see the comet's tail in the profile, its length in the picture would have exceeded 10 minutes of arc! Comet comes into confrontation and we have a good opportunity to get pictures of the coma of a comet. Maybe it will be done and on large telescopes.

A Youtuber posted this today ... this page explains the game http://www.ready.illinois.gov/  And you can download the game for Windows & Mac here http://www.iema.illinois.gov/iema/EarthquakeGame/Play_the_Game.html

I"d love to see what you folks think of it  lol

Dead Birds were found just a few days ago, then Fish, and now they are being found World Wide.  Some people are linking this mass killings to the Earth's Magnetic Fleild.   Any ideas folks?

Before it's News
By Greg Ericson (Editor)
 Contributor profile | More stories
Sunday, December 12, 2010 8:08

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EngAS0zFjf8

Poleshift has started and it's moving fast. We see all over the world strange weather patterns and increasing amounts of floods. Many people have reported significant changes in sunset/sunrise times. Also moon's and constellation positions seems to be altered in some weird manner.

A lot more people are aying attention now

Most of the time, hints of something big happening, come in small changes that people do not always notice at first.  California has a very large Citrus crop, some say the biggest in the US ... normally the fruits are in the stores around Walloween ... this year they are still on the trees after Thanksgiving ... a month late?

Has anyone noticed the same thing in their gardens or feilds?

La mayoría de las veces, las sugerencias de que ocurra algo grande, vienen en pequeños cambios que la gente no siempre se cuenta al principio. California tiene una cosecha de cítricos de gran tamaño, algunos dicen que el más grande en los EE.UU. ... normalmente los frutos están en las tiendas alrededor Walloween ... este año están todavía en los árboles después de Acción de Gracias ... un mes de retraso?

¿Alguien ha notado lo mismo en sus jardines o feilds?